Commonly, eliciting is used to ask learners to come up with vocabulary and language forms and rules, and to brainstorm a topic at the start of a skills lesson. The definition of the term in the Dictionary of Language Teaching and Applied Linguistics, ‘Techniques or procedures which a teacher uses to get learners to actively produce speech or writing', suggests that there may be wider applications.
Principles and advantages
Eliciting is based on several premises:
- Collectively, students have a great deal of knowledge, both of the language and of the real world. This knowledge needs to be activated and used constructively
- The teaching of new knowledge is often based on what the learners already know
- Questioning assists in self-discovery, which makes information more memorable.
Eliciting helps to develop a learner-centred classroom and a stimulating environment, while making learning memorable by linking new and old information. Eliciting is not limited to language and global knowledge. The teacher can elicit ideas, feelings, meaning, situations, associations and memories. For the teacher, eliciting is a powerful diagnostic tool, providing key information about what the learners know or don't know, and therefore a starting point for lesson planning. Eliciting also encourages teachers to be flexible and to move on rather than dwell on information which is already known.
Tools for eliciting
Language and ideas cannot be elicited without some input from the teacher, and eliciting is certainly not an excuse for not presenting language in a clear context. Students also need prompts, associations and reminders in order to jog their memories.
- Often, the teacher provides stimulus using visuals or the board. When working on the simple present for daily routines, for example, a picture or drawing of a house and a clock combined with mime can be used to elicit both the names of household items and common verbs:
T: Six o'clock. Where is she?
T: Yes, she's in bed, sleeping. Seven-thirty, every day?
S: Get up
T: Good, she gets up at seven-thirty. Eight o'clock, every day?
S: Eat. Breakfast
T: Well done. Listen: She has breakfast at eight o'clock
- The teacher may also model new structures or lexis before it is introduced as the target language:
T: Do you like coffee?
S: Yes (I do).
T: Do you like tea?
S: Yes I do
T: Do you like milk?
S: No (I don't)
T: What's the question? Ask me.
- A situational dialogue, example sentences or a listening/reading text may provide the context from which the target language is elicited. In this case, the teacher is asking the learners to notice how a particular function is expressed, and eliciting is combined with concept questions. In a text or dialogue about the future:
T: Is he talking about the past, present or future?
T: Does he know / is he sure about the future?
T: Right. It's a prediction. What verb does he use?
T: Good. Can you give me an example?
- Eliciting ideas and background information also requires input. This may come from a teacher's anecdote or story, a text, pictures, or a video, and involves the sharing of knowledge between teacher and learners. Information is often elicited onto a mind-map on the board, but it is important that all the students have a record of collective knowledge, and may find one of the many kinds of graphic organiser useful. Reading lessons often begin with a photo or headline from the text which serves a dual purpose in providing a stimulus for eliciting and a prompt for predicting content. KWL charts are ideal records of what students already Know, what they Want to know, and what they have Learnt by the end of the lesson, and point to the conclusion that eliciting can take place at any stage of a lesson and often indicates what should happen next.
While eliciting clearly contributes to student involvement, it does not always produce the desired or expected results. Questions such as ‘Who can tell me something about....?' may be greeted with stony silence. Students are wrongly labelled as lacking knowledge or being too shy when there are often cultural reasons for their reticence.
In many cultures, students are not encouraged to volunteer information or ask questions while in others the teacher is seen as the sole provider of knowledge. The problem is reinforced by the fact that many units in course materials begin with open elicitation questions which create the possibility of making grammatical or pronunciation errors and therefore losing face in front of classmates.
In cultures where the group is more important than the individual it is unacceptable to stand out either as a success or as a failure. Even with constant encouragement, it is difficult to break down entrenched attitudes and beliefs, and certain strategies may be required:
- Nominate students rather than waiting for volunteers. The student is then not responsible for being made to stand out from the group.
- Give learners time to prepare an answer. Spontaneity may be ideal, but students will be more confident if they are given a moment to think about or even to write down an answer.
- Ensure that there is no right or wrong answer involved. General questions such as ‘What's your favourite colour?' or ‘What kind of music do you listen to?' are more likely to produce answers than those requiring specific knowledge.
- Encourage rather than correct. When eliciting language, comments such as ‘nearly right' and ‘try again' are more constructive than ‘no, does anyone else know the right answer?' Try not to correct when learners are volunteering background information about a topic - confidence-building, not accuracy is important here.
Tips for eliciting
- Eliciting is a basic technique and should be used regularly, not only at the beginning of a lesson but whenever it is necessary and appropriate.
- Don't try to ‘pull teeth'. Prolonged silence or incorrect answers suggest that input is required from the teacher.
- Don't ask students to repeat incorrect answers, but ask a variety of students to repeat a good answer.
- Acknowledge or give feedback to each answer with gestures or short comments.
- Provide sufficient context or information. Eliciting differs from Socratic questioning in that it is designed to find out what the learners know rather than to lead them to a conclusion which only the teacher knows.
- Learners can elicit from each other, particularly during brainstorming activities. This helps to build confidence and group cohesion as well as shifting the focus away from the teacher.
- At lower levels, more guided questioning is needed. Open-ended questions should be avoided as the learners are unlikely to have the language to answer them to their own satisfaction.
The success of eliciting depends largely on the attitudes of teachers and learners to their respective roles. Ideally it promotes the notion of an exchange of information, helps to break down traditional teacher-centredness, and begins to establish a variety of interaction patterns in the classroom. It is also fundamental to the inductive approach to teaching language and to learning through tasks and self-discovery, and a simple and effective way of getting learners to produce language.
Steve Darn, Freelance Trainer, Izmir, Turkey
Funda Çetin, Izmir University of Economics
As an ESL teacher, of course I use eliciting to get responses from teachers, but I appreciate this article which makes me think about it more consciously and encourages me to use it more as an approach while I'm teaching.
Eliciting as class technique has more advantages than one might think. The article points to some of the benefits it has on teaching.
For me the central point is the opportunity elicitation provides to make students' knowledge,emotions and thinking a great value to share with others.
Students come to discover how great a contribution they bring to the lesson as individual learners with different learning,intellectual and emotional dimensions.Consequently, by contributing to the making of the lesson, learning happens naturally. And most important,there is the unavoidable personal growth of students as human beings since they come to see the necessity,usefulness and need for complete involvement in the class experience and thus take responsibility for their own learning.
Eliciting can be very useful in a grammar class, especially when you want students to try and figure out rules on their own.
Yes, nice ideas, quite obvious and not new for me. What is new is the spreading to the East (at least to Hungary) of the American attitude made conspicuous in some honest films. By this attitude, students don't want to answer, don't want to share anything with each other or at least the teacher, saying what they like is nobody's business, or like that, and sometimes they don't even want to hear the questions, let alone learn something. Boredom is also there - mine, when the only answer I get is: games; or: watch TV.
In maths, you don't elicit much, so the problem is not so evident, but it's pretty general. I'd rather quit education. It has become rather depressing. I'm looking forward to some really new ideas and a chance to solve problems of real classrooms with genuine lack of interest. Until then, let's try not to pretend that we'll get any kind of answer to even the best questions put forward with the best intention. The students may not have such good intentions. Then what? A basic clash of interests.
Steve Darn"s suggestions for a teacher in elicitation method of motivating and teaching his pupils is good and useful. Elicitation will be a boon to a teacher to keep his class in living condition.
Thanks for this precious article. As a comment, I'd like to mention the point of motivation in the classroom, that is the core of the success of each class activity including elicitation. I think that the reason why some teachers don't get responses from their pupils, when eliciting, is mainly related to the shortage or even the lack of students motivation. Motivate your students then you can gain their points of view, ideas and emotion esily.
It is not an approach but a technique to get students to participate, to build up their own learning, to personalise the class...
say, if you give examples to students, they may find that your examples are too yours and not theirs. If you use their information to build your examples they may pay more attention, understand better, or be more creative later on when participating in class...
Is there any book about elicitation? Cheaper one with good quality, please. Most of English books are very expensive for people living in under-developing country.
Great job! I particularly liked the "tips for eliciting" section of the article.
Very informative and interesting article. It helps a lot but as Kiana, I´m interested in a book that may help with techniques on how elicit, to me it´s quite hard to do it qith grammar in high levels.
I dont think there is any book particularly but one needs to find particular chapters in books aimed at teacher trainers, trainees such as TKT, CELTA, DELTA prep material or professional development materials etc
I really like the ideas of the eliciting, and I want to get more ideas about teaching teachers the elicitinig language.