Questions & answers

In this section we publish questions and answers sent in by users of the site about English language teaching topics.

To reply to a question click on Add new comment. Please note that your comment will need to be approved by a moderator before it is added and we only publish comments which offer new ideas or advice to the discussion.

If you would like to submit a question for others to answer then contact us.

TALK
questions 
Reading comprehension

I am an English teacher in a technical college in Vietnam. I am assigned to teach reading comprehension. Could you give me tips on scanning, skimming, paraphrasing, and summarising a text? I look forward to your replies.

Do you have any advice and tips on this aspects of reading comprehension? How do you differentiate between scanning and skimming?How can you help students with their summary skills? Contact us

This question is from Ngu Yenan Hvu, Vietnam

Comments

Submitted on 20 March, 2008 - 02:40
Jenny, Netherlands
  • An introductory exercise to teach the difference between skimming and scanning is this:
    • Take a readingcomprehension text that is not too difficult.
    • Ask the students to first read the text quickly and then think of a title for the text and/or each paragraph. It's important to give them a time limit, so they are not able to read everything in detail. If this task is too difficult, begin by asking them to use a highlighter to mark words they think are important. Keep the time pressure on!
    • For scanning, give them more time. Supply them with questions about the text that require detailed answers which they can only find by reading carefully and sometimes changing the language slightly. Explain the importance of reading the questions first, particularly on standardized tests.
    • Once they students can locate the information and understand the subtle changes that may be made in the wording of the questions or answers, they can create their own reading comprehension questions. This is a great way to get them to pick through texts and look for useable detail.
    • Ask each student to make a multiple choice test based on the same text.
    • Compare the questions and alternatives and choose the best ones for a sample test.
    • Even better, divide the group in two and ask each half to prepare a test for the other half.
  • Paraphrasing can be tricky because students will want to use that skill when writing, and there can be grey area between paraphrasing and plagiarism. Be sure to explain this.
  • Finally, summarizing skills can be taught by moving from the shortest possible summary to a broader one.
    • Ask the students to start by summarizing the text (book, article,review, description) in just one phrase - not even a complete sentence. Reduce the information to its essence.
    • Build up from there, moving to whole sentences, groups of sentences, a well-organized paragraph and finally to three, four or five paragraphs (including an introduction & conclusion).

Good luck!

Hoa Huong Duong, Vietnam
As a Vietnamese English teacher, I've found that we can improve reading skills for students by :

1. Translating short paragraphs (not sentences) from Vietnamese to English. The paragraphs must be the translation from English writings which will be referred to as key.
2. Through the "translation" exercises, students can find out by themselves idioms, phasal verbs, and especially how to express their ideas in anEnglish way of thinking, not Vietnamese.
3. Finally, give them writing assignments about what they're interested in, for example : Will you live with your parents after your marriage or not ? How is a nice colleague?

Wish you success.

Silvia Tamara, Peru
Ngu, a time limit is very important. When skimming, make them read quickly 2 or 3 times and exchange information after each try. If needed, and the end, make them aware of how much time they've spent to get the general idea. In scanning, help them identify exactly what they have to look for. After the time limit, they can discuss their answers. In summarising, underlining the main ideas is useful. They can exchange opinions with a classmate and work together on paraphrasing that idea. Hope you find some of this useful.

© British Council, 10 Spring Gardens, London SW1A 2BN, UK         © BBC World Service, Bush House, Strand, London WC2B 4PH, UK