I sometimes think some of our discussions in ELT have become something more idealistic than practical because we have overlooked the impact of business practices on what we do. No doubt in a lot of circumstances, ELT is a money-making business. What we do is directly linked to profit making, if not, we must help to cut costs. For instance, English teachers are sometimes blamed by the university administrator for using a lot more paper than the other departments because this is not cost effective. For us this is probably inevitable as it is part of our teaching methodology to create different activities and tasks using paper for students to do in class.
To what extent have the 'practices of money-making' affected what you do at your workplace? How do you cope with that?







Comments
Heath
That's a great point elchwa.
Teacher training and professional development workshops very often do send teachers straight back into their companies/organisations with a mindset that they're are right and the organisations they work for a wrong.
Similarly, marketing departments, sales departments, and middle-management tend to see teachers as irritating pests that come and go. I've seen middle management give great speeches thanking effective sales and customer services and not mentioning academic teams at all.
It does seem Academics and Business are at direct odds at times, doesn't it. But it shouldn't be, and while educators can't directly change the attitude of the other departments, they can change their own attitude (and perhaps indirectly end up in all departments getting along and being more successful).
Suggestions welcome!
elchwa
I agree with you, Heath, that teacher training programmes do have an important role to play in at least raising teachers' awareness of business in ELT.
On the other hand, the top management team in a private school are very often people who know very little about education, let alone ELT. I have come across someone who claimed to be a Phd holder and a retired managing director of an airline company. He was hired as the Academic Vice President in a private college in China. He is one of those who thinks English can be taught by native-speaker housewives, so why need to pay so much to Masters' holders? Communicating with this kind of people can be extremely difficult and frustrating - it always takes up a lot of effort and time. This has caused the poor Head of English Department a lot of stress as he is the 'middleman' between the teaching staff and the management.
What are your experiences as a DOS or Head of Department in dealing with the management? How do we communicate effectively with people who do not understand education, but only care about 'figures'?
Heath
It's more than just management. As a Director of Studies you actually need to 'middleman' 4 main different groups of people (more than this actually, but these 4 tends to have the more conflicting aims, in my experience):
Different groups of people naturally results in misunderstandings and people (thinking) they are working at cross purposes. Truth is, imagine an education company...
All of them are absolutely essential to an effective operation, so they all need to understand each other.
Should we, the DoS and the teachers, take the first step in trying to understand? Probably not, but if they won't and we won't then things will never improve. So my suggestion is not to help them understand education, and not to 'deal with the management', but to:
Start off by helping the teachers to understand the other departments.
When they see our interest in their work, and when our interest in their work makes things run more efficiently and effectively, they'll be much more likely to take an interest in our work.
(nb. This is all in hindsight, and as a DoS I never took this approach myself... but next time I return to DoS work, I intend on trying).
girishseshamani
You have introduced a beautiful topic for discussion. I have been training over the last 8 years. Without exception, this is a common problem down here, that the expenses of stationary is very high for the English Language and are eating into the profits.......!!!!!!!!!!!
As you rightly pointed out, it is inevitable for ELT trainers to use paper. Down here, apart from a few exceptions, education is seen as a profitable business. Genuine academicians are a rarity. The way institutes generate visibility for themselves using different medias smacks of hypocrisy.
Being an individual who has decided to dedicate his entire life to teaching, I find this difficult to take. Let me also make a mention here, that lot of youngsters have dedicated their life for teaching which is a positive sign. Lot of individuals drop lucrative job offers and follow their heart.
Whenever any material is to be given to students, I spend money from my own pocket. I never compromise on this aspect. I know it is a futile exercise to cast pearls before a swine