Do you think that teachers can forget using stick ?
we know the types of reinforcement is positive and negative but some teachers use a negative way as the best way to deal students
Using stick as a punishments. How can we deal with some students without STICK ?







Comments
girishseshamani
There is no set process or method with reference to disciplining of students. Using stick or shouting at the students shows that you are not capable of controlling the class and you will lose the respect of the students.
I always maintain that the first day for a teacher at any institution is the most critical factor. The impression that you create on the first day, stays with them throughout and more importantly, gets passed to subsequent batches. If you try to win the students over to your side by trying to be their favourite, it becomes very difficult for you later on, to change your methodology. You will see lot of resistance from the students and shouting at them will only further damage your credibility.
If you sense that the class is going out of control, maintaining continuous eye contact without speaking will have a powerful effect. You could also pick up students who act smart or play pranks, by asking them to come out and do an embarrassing activity. You could also have the batch system where students are graded on two parameters, as in knowledge and discipline. The green batch should be worn by students who are involved and disciplined. The red badge is for the other crowd and it is titled pigs. Ensure that they wear this batch throughout the day.
swif
Is stick being used metaphorically here?
I think forcing students to wear pig badges is not a good idea.
Stuart Wiffin
Heath
Oh, what a pity. I read an excellent article on this not long ago, on onestopenglish.com. Unfortunately it seems to have been moved to their locked articles (you can read it only if you subscribe) - it wasn't before. If I remember correctly it was by Adrian Tennant, but I could be wrong.
Four things I remember from it, that I think are particularly useful and relevant are:
That gave me a few ideas.
Not sure if 'the stick' counts though. That's a bit rough.
giganick
I agree with the previous writer, the most important thing is to have something appropriate to the students ability and adequately motivating for them to be doing. (What's the phrase: idle thumbs do the devils work? Something like that.)
That said, you need to get them started. Always have the students stand up and silent at the beginning of the lesson. Have them say good morning. Have them sit down quietly until you explain what you are doing or you activate communication. Sometimes it is best policy to wait for the students to stand silently. You may be waiting for only one or two students in the end, but rarely can they last more than a minute. Sometimes it is worth requesting silence. Sometimes it is worth barking out a complaint. Showing anger doesn't necessarily equate to showing weakness, no matter what the popular opinion may be. Controlling anger doesn't mean suppressing it. Direct it effectively. Some days will be easier than others. Sometimes you can potter about making your presence felt before asking them to stand up, and they will stand up automatically, as you, for example, prepare the DVD. The beginning of the lesson is the most important. Ensure it works and the rest will be easy.
Then keep them involved.
It's nice to stand to say goodbye as well.
I don't use any punishments, except the occasional scolding. The students see the effect in their grades.
Good luck.