TeachingEnglish
      Principled writing 1

      I argue for the fact that Writing must be Principled. Reading and writing are to be acquired as communicative skills, thus the more we employ strategies and approaches to develop these skills, the more fluent and accurate our Ss will be.

      First of all, I arrange process writing 1. schemata activation, motivation for the language, prepraration for the language, 2. thesis development, paragraph development, choice of cohesive devices, writing from notes, ending up with a given phrase, following a plan, following a format and register, solving a problem 3. reflection on spelling and reasoning errors, sharing the writing with the group, peer editing.

      Teaching writing is a "long-term project" (Davies, 2008) beginning from the 3rd grade through the 11th grade in Russia. Ss write a lot of compositions in Russian. When we start writing in English, that's a real "dual" or a very anxious process because Ss tend to write it in Russian, then translate it into English.

      So, I encourage my Ss not to do so by brainstorming/eliciting and together with learners go over the mistakes, looking at the sources, going as deep as necessary for the learner to distinguish "what's being produced" and "what should be produced". The result is composition or essay in English: neither taken from a book nor written by anybody. Though it's a tedious process and I explain my Ss the reasons to go through all these stages of writing from data collection to publishing. This principled writing does a lot of good during the exams.

      Do your students fear of writing? How do you start teaching writing? Should it be so strictly principled?

      Average: 2 (1 vote)

      Comments

      babakartal's picture
      babakartal
      Submitted on 27 January, 2012 - 22:56

      Hi Victoria,

       There are models to write in their books. According to these models they try to write. Sometimes they fear but in time they see their successes. I always remind them " don't afraid making mistakes" this motivation is for their courages..

       thanks for your sharing...

      Victoria Kamchatka's picture
      Victoria Kamchatka
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 05:37

      Yes, there are models to write, but very often they don't understand the models ( in my practice), that's why I make it principled and explicit.

      korolevald's picture
      korolevald
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 07:34

      Hi Victoria, 

      Do your Ss find enough arguments to dwell on the topic? As for mine,  there is lack of personal life experience to give right arguments and make conclusions. So I agree it's important to collect data.

       

      Victoria Kamchatka's picture
      Victoria Kamchatka
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 07:43

      Thanks for the comment. Yes, sometimes not. I guide them with the questions to help them draw conclusions. Collecting info expands their background knowledge.

      Evgeniya_Zimina's picture
      Evgeniya_Zimina
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 10:32

      Victoria, I think your approach is absolutely right, especially when we take the Russian National Exam into consideration. This year one more point is added to the essay marking - essays should be original, and not borrowed from textbooks. When students use models from books, they tend to use texts (or fragments of texts) from books, too, and many essays look identical.

      I also discourage my one-to-one students from writing in Russian first and then translating it into English. It is time-consumung and prevents them from developing their skill of thinking in the target language.  

      Victoria Kamchatka's picture
      Victoria Kamchatka
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 11:02

      Hi Evgeniya,

      I know that some teachers advise their Ss to learn sample essays by rote to feel comfortable and knowledgeable at the exam. They can learn cliches and cohesive devices but not the content. That's why we activate Ss' backgound knowledge and then teaching them something new.

      Evgeniya_Zimina's picture
      Evgeniya_Zimina
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 11:16

      Hi, Victoria!

      Unfortunately, I know some teachers who make their ss learn the whole texts by heart and advise to squeeze them into exam essays. Sad, isn't it? Cliches an d cohesive devices are another thing. They definitely should be memorized.

      Victoria Kamchatka's picture
      Victoria Kamchatka
      Submitted on 28 January, 2012 - 13:35

      Here's my second blog on Principled Writing. Do your Ss make notes and keep journals to organize their writing?

      http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/blogs/victoria-kamchatka/principled-wr...