TeachingEnglish
      Major Teaching Mistakes - 4

      Mistake #4: Give Tests That Are Too Long.

      Engineering professors routinely give too long exams for most of their students. Problems, involving a lot of time-consuming mathematical analysis. The few impulsive students finish with a few careless mistakes, while reflective learners who never get to some problems get failing grades.

      One major factor causes engineering enrollments to decrease by %40 or more in the first two years of the curriculum. When concerns are raised about the impact this attrition on the engineering pipeline.

      Fallacy:

      the dropouts are all incompetent or lazy and unqualified to be engineers. WRONG

      Studies correlating grades of graduates with subsequent career success, negligible.

      Students dropping out of engineering have the same academic profile as those who stay.

      Slow, careful and methodical students, better engineers than quick and careless students.

      To evaluate your students' potential, test their mastery of the knowledge and skills you are teaching, not their problem-solving speed.

      Testing point:

      1. Take the test yourself.
      2. Time youself.
      3. Make sure to give the students at least three times longer to take it than you.
      4. You don't have to stop and think about it.
      5. If a test, challenging, the ratio should be four or five to one for the test to be fair.

      Average: 5 (1 vote)

      Comments

      nahla_shaw's picture
      nahla_shaw
      Submitted on 4 February, 2012 - 19:40

       

      What you wrote makes sense to me. I will take your advice into account when I write my exams. Indeed, it is not fair to test them on speed. 

      Thank you.

      lemanulas's picture
      lemanulas
      Submitted on 4 February, 2012 - 21:58

      yep, rightfor me;time problems turn into a tragedy for the students..so question & time should be in equilibrium...thanks..

      CagriHoca's picture
      CagriHoca
      Submitted on 4 February, 2012 - 22:25

      nahla_shaw you're welcome, thank you very much for your comment. 

      lemanulas you're right! thank you very much for commenting.

      babakartal's picture
      babakartal
      Submitted on 4 February, 2012 - 22:32

      Hi, the_message,

      I follow your "series" .Thanks a lot.

      asligokturk's picture
      asligokturk
      Submitted on 4 February, 2012 - 23:23

      Hello,

      Your post brought back some old memories; I was not a good test taker (I am still not good with sitting exams) but I am vey good with performance based assessment. I believe that the fact that I could not ace long-parts after part exam was because I was not learning.

      Also, as a learner I suffered a lot from ecological validity. They asked us multiple choice exams but life was different. I was expected to carry out presentations, portfolios and projects.

      Thanks for the post :)

      singerina's picture
      singerina
      Submitted on 4 February, 2012 - 23:30

      Make sure to give the students at least three times longer to take it than you.

       

      good advice ;)

      CagriHoca's picture
      CagriHoca
      Submitted on 9 February, 2012 - 11:52

      babakartal thank you very much,

      asligokturk thank you very much for your comment. I'm same as you. It's like the chair is getting harder for every second I sit for an exam :)

      singerina thank you very much for the comment.