TeachingEnglish
      A final bee

      This is my last blog. It's been a privilege to write for you, and a pleasure to read your views. And thank you for your many encouraging remarks. Those of us who write these pieces are delighted to learn that teachers find our work helpful: that's what we hope to achieve.

      However, while I'm delighted to receive compliments on what I do (who isn't?), these are occasionally so complimentary as to make me nervous. Let me close this series of blogs by releasing a final bee from my bonnet: it's to do with respect for authority.

      We all benefit greatly from other people's experience and thinking, but I feel it's also important not to have too much reverence for well-known names – this isn't good either for those who revere or for those who are revered. There have been, and are, plenty of self-appointed gurus in the language-teaching business; some of them have done good, some have done harm. Perhaps Eliot was being a little extreme when he wrote:
      'Do not let me hearof the wisdom of old men, but rather of their folly',
      but it's good to be critical.
      If one doesn't agree with what some 'expert' says, one may be wrong, but not necessarily: one may be absolutely right. We mustn't be afraid to trust our own experience and intuitions, especially because in our field, as in all the social sciences, there's a lot of nonsense around.

       There's also a lot of sense, but sometimes it's hard to tell. Impressive terminology can conceal serious confusion. When people talk about 'strategies', 'pragmatics', 'process' or 'identity', for example, I often have trouble focusing on what exactly is meant by these terms, valuable though the discussion may be. (So if you are planning to write a paper on a process strategy for teaching the pragmatics of identity, do me a favour and don't tell me.) As teachers, we have a duty to communicate clearly; we also have a right to expect clarity from those who communicate with us. Years ago I came to a comforting conclusion: if I'm reading something written by an eminent authority, in my own central area of professional interest, and I can't make head or tail of it, it's probably not my fault.

       Let me leave you with a poem.

       

      THANK YOU, MASTER

      ‘Master
      how should we live?’

      ‘Respect yourself.
      Follow your own instinct
      for what is good.
      Call no man master.
      Do not turn men into gods.’

      ‘Thank you, master.
      We will obey your commands
      to the letter.’

       

      Warmest regards, and good luck.

      Michael

      Michael's now finished his period as our Guest Writer - many thanks to all of you who contributed to the discussion on his blog.

      Average: 4.7 (19 votes)

      Comments

      CoffeeAddict's picture
      CoffeeAddict
      Submitted on 11 February, 2011 - 14:44

      I will also obey :-). Thank you!

      CoffeeAddict

      jlshylla's picture
      jlshylla
      Submitted on 11 February, 2011 - 17:14

      Thank you very much Michael for sharing with us your insights, comments and knowledge. It is very rare that one gets to 'talk' with an internationally well known person such as you. You have done all of us a great service by making yourself available through your blog on Teachingenglish.org.uk. May you continue to be blessed with a sound mind and a sound body, always. Best wishes and regards *Bah Michael (*Bah in my language is a word used to refer to an elderly male person.) *Khublei (is *God bless you & thank you) Jacob

      ElenaV's picture
      ElenaV
      Submitted on 11 February, 2011 - 20:50

      Dear Sir,

      Thank you for this encouraging and inspiring post! It was not a common practice to question eminent authorities where I grew up. The situation has changed in my motherland and in many places worldwide. I hope that my children will live  in a society where sound criticism and inquisitive “why” will not be a “crime”.

      Blogathon is my first experience of sharing my thoughts, teaching ideas and tips publicly. I am delighted to see that people respond and find them useful. Now, having read your post I might even think of presenting at one of the ELT Conferences that I have been attending year after year, “lurking”, taking notes, wondering how people have the courage to present.

      With thanks,

      Elena

      crystalheart's picture
      crystalheart
      Submitted on 11 February, 2011 - 23:24

      Dear Mr Swan,

      I remember when I was a little pupil, it was your Basic English Usage grammar book the first time I studied English grammar. I think I was in a preparatory class at the age of 12 in Istanbul then. 

      Now I'm an English teacher and it's my pride to teach students with your books.

      Thanks for your endeavours for us.

      Harsh Kadepurkar's picture
      Harsh Kadepurkar
      Submitted on 12 February, 2011 - 07:22

      Thank you very much for your advice regarding respecting the masters but not looking at them as 'Gods'.

      We will miss you on this website. Please find time to visit the site whenever you can.

      Your advice reminds me of the advice I give to my teacher trainers who have to go back to their towns/cities and organize in-service training programmes. I tell them:

      Please remember that every town/city has at least a couple of elderly teachers of English who are highly respected in the region. If they are aware of the current thinking in ELT, consider this as a very good thing for you. Go and meet them, and if possible, invite them for the inaugural or closing functions. However, if you feel that they are not in touch with the changes, follow a different strategy. Go and meet them, offer your respects, but see to it that they do not come anywhere near your programme venue. Remember, if they come, you will have a difficult time. Since they are highly respected by almost everybody in the town, your trainee teachers will insist on arranging a session or two of these teachers. It is possible that they will say something which will be totally opposite to what you have said and then you will be in trouble! 

      Harsh 

      merveoflaz's picture
      merveoflaz
      Submitted on 12 February, 2011 - 20:08

      Dear Michael,

      It was an honour for me to write to you. And getting a reply made me so happy, too. I'd like to thank you for sharing your ideas and experiences with us.

      I started blogging with the inspiration I got from Blogathon and I think I will go on. This is a great chance to express ourselves, share our knowledge and learn from each other. Besides it gives us big opprtunities like communcating with some gurus (like you:), reading their words and asking for opinions.

      Thanks again and bye (for now:))

      zifeiskurti's picture
      zifeiskurti
      Submitted on 12 February, 2011 - 20:37

      I just want to say thank you.

      Iwould really miss your useful practical ideas on teaching.

      thank you very much.

      Debris Rutkauskaite's picture
      Debris Rutkauskaite
      Submitted on 13 February, 2011 - 18:11

      Thank you very much indeed, Michael, (and I apologise for this American familiarity),

      for your response to my comments and to those of others, all of which I have read with interest. I can see now better how to navigate making a descriptive course also practically useful to the students who are not very advanced in English. Without making too much of authority, I hope we shall hear from you on other platforms. I am looking forward to it.

      Marija Liudvika

      Michael Swan's picture
      Michael Swan
      Submitted on 13 February, 2011 - 19:25

      Elena, do pluck up your courage and do a presentation. You'll plant some good seeds.

      Regards

      Michael

      ElenaV's picture
      ElenaV
      Submitted on 14 February, 2011 - 22:19

      Dear Mr. Swan,

      your reply is deeply appreciated!

      Kind Regards,

      Elena