TeachingEnglish
      Evaluation dilemmas

      How do you evaluate students` achievements? We usually evaluate them according to the results of the tests. What should we evaluate the level of knowledge or their efforts when they study the material? Do the results of the tests really reflect the level of skills which our students have? Should we assess the level of knowledge or the level of development of our students?

      I always ask myself these questions when I try to evaluate my students` progress. I often have students who try to learn the material and do a lot of work but they can`t pass tests with excellent grades. At the same time they got their personal results and it means that they develop their skills more slowly that the syllabus suggests. What should I evaluate: personal development of students, their individual progress or the standard level of knowledge which a particular unit suggests?

      The problem is that when students make progress in their pace and it doesn`t correspond with the standards of the system, it 1) demotivates them, 2) lowers their self-esteem and 3) devaluates their work. At the same time students should understand that their personal knowledge is lower than the standard is.

      I show my students their personal development in the context of standard in these situations. I offer them additional opportunities for evaluation such as project work, portfolio, essays and other tasks where they can express their level of knowledge. The more possibilities we create to assess students` skills the more chances they get to be assessed.      

      Average: 2 (1 vote)

      Comments

      Mike Le Prof's picture
      Mike Le Prof
      Submitted on 23 February, 2012 - 19:59

      That's a very important post, Irina!

      I guess you're quite right in the methods of assessment you use.

      And I think that sometimes tests don't show the real picture of ss' development.

      OxanaKhrushcheva's picture
      OxanaKhrushcheva
      Submitted on 25 February, 2012 - 11:02

      Thanks for your post!It's really necessary to discuss such issues because everyone faces the dilemmas of assessment.As the issue is hot it's been already touched upon by blogger-colleagues and it was mentioned that we have to evaluate the final results, skills and knowledge of students individually.In certain cases we even can turn a blind eye to students' failures during the academic year if they show a brilliant result at exams; I do follow this strategy with hard working but rather weak students whose exam answers appear to be much better than before; I give them good marks to motivate them for further success and hard work.

      Mike Le Prof's picture
      Mike Le Prof
      Submitted on 25 February, 2012 - 18:57

      Oxana, there has been a discussion at our department about such cases. Some teachers were bewildered: when they received the exam, there were some ss who didn't frequent their classes. Their answers were excellent but the teachers said that they had to lower the marks because of that. That's why they asked to change the form: from exam to credit.

      OxanaKhrushcheva's picture
      OxanaKhrushcheva
      Submitted on 26 February, 2012 - 04:01

      I see what you mean but it's impossible at our university because we assess our students not only at exams but also by modules twice a semester; if they miss classes they will be expelled before the session.