TeachingEnglish
      Behind Bars - English lessons to inmates

      This is planned as a journal – a regular account of the English course I’ll be running for the second year for prison inmates. The course is a voluntary initiative and is co-ordinated by an organisation called ‘Progetto Carcere’ whose hard work and commitment goes a significant way to compensating for the lack of openings otherwise available to inmates in this prison in northern Italy. They are victims of overcrowding in more ways than one – there are simply too many of them for the prison authorities to cope with (the prison was built to hold 400 inmates and currently accommodates 800). Escorting them to, for example, the gym requires personnel and time, so when the demands on these resources get too stretched the simplest solution is just to leave everyone locked in their cells (in reality each inmate is currently allowed one 40-minute session in the gym monthly - the gym re-opened recently after a three-year closure).

       

      Today it's back to prison -- I think I’ve missed the place. If you put a lot into your lessons it takes a lot out of you and I must say that when I finished last year's course it actually left me feeling more than a little drained. I wasn't really aware of it until the times I thought about starting again, and then I really wondered “Am I ready for it yet?”
      Nonetheless, it was certainly one of the most important teaching experiences in my rather long career, immensely rewarding on different levels - but I suppose that as in other things, the reward is in proportion to the challenge.
      So, a new challenge today. In half an hour from now it will be ID checks, metal detectors, steel gates, echoes and cages. And -- my students: 16 of them apparently. Who knows how things will turn out?


      Later ……….
      The usual suspects – the pen-pushers got things off to a poor start. At the post metal-detector stage one of the guards who I often saw last year - and was never the most enthusiastically co-operative - recognised me and mentioned with a wry smile that he thought that when I reached the library section I would find no-one waiting for me: he thought that the official papers were not there. He was right. I was greeted by the duty warden’s blank expressions followed by lots of flicking through ledgers and stacks of photocopies – all to no avail. Fortunately, with some friendly pressure from the man who co-ordinates all voluntary programmes, phone calls were made and , yes, the course was authorised and due to start today.
      Half an hour later a couple of my students showed up and we were ushered to our classroom – old school-desks and bare browny-grey partition walls which are as sound-proof as a stain. There wasn’t really time to do that much – and I wanted to wait for any others to turn up, which happened in dribs and drabs.
      First lessons with new groups are always testing – as a teacher you need to make lots of inviting space for your students to feel at ease about stepping into. You need to see and hear as much as you can – the people you are teaching are probably strangers to each other and they want to sound things out too. In a normal classroom it requires intuition and experience to handle these situations in a way that creates enough space for information to transmit without putting people on the spot. In a prison the pressures are probably significantly greater - in any group of young(ish) males who meet for the first time there is going to be a lot of sizing each other up and a degree of wariness. Basically what you want to achieve is a sense of ‘respect’: you are there to do a job and do it seriously. You take the task at hand seriously, and you take the people who are there seriously, and you want to walk away feeling you’ve all achieved something worthwhile. What you need is to engender ‘consensus’ – that’s the vehicle that will carry everything forward.
      In the end I had seven students: two Italians, three Romanians, one Colombian and one young man from North Africa, I think – the acoustic interference from the next room was too much and I had already asked people to repeat things so often that I got a serious glimpse of what it means to be hard-of-hearing.
      From what I was able to learn we have a big range of levels – there’s a 19-year-old Romanian whose English seems excellent: he says he started learning when he was three. “That’s unusual” I said, “I’m not a usual guy” he replied. One of the Italians speaks reasonable English too: I asked those who knew a few words to introduce themselves, and invited the others to tell me what – if anything - they had understood or guessed. The Italian man had studied English at High School and university and had used English in his work in Zurich where he was in the financial field. The rest are – or claim to be – beginners, although one of the Romanian men understood everything. He also came across as rather intense: “We have to get a lot from this course,” he told the others, “we mustn’t waste time with simple things – we must do this intensively if we want results.” Hmmm.
      Next lesson I hope to have the full group – apparently down to twelve now - and the real challenge will begin. Things are not helped by circumstances: I had asked for two one-hour lessons weekly, like last year, but they can only let me do one 90-minute lesson a week, which, in addition to the extreme range of levels, I’m seriously worried might reduce all our efforts to little more than enjoyable time-killing. Mind you, with these guys often spending 22 hours a day in a cell the size of a caravan with three others, enjoyable time-killing could even be all right.

      Average: 3.8 (14 votes)

      Comments

      Isasan's picture
      Isasan
      Submitted on 21 December, 2011 - 20:22

       

      Hi Iain,

      I think it must be really worthwhile teaching English to prisoners.  Not only because it is useful to learn some English, but also because it can encourage them to think and use their time in a productive way.  In addition to this, it can cheer them up and help them to have some hope for their future.

      Congratulations Iain!

      Merry Christmas!

      Isabel

      Stephen Greene's picture
      Stephen Greene
      Submitted on 21 December, 2011 - 20:38

      A really interesting challenge you have here.  I am looking forward to reading about your experiences in the future.

      I have two questions for you; How did your students feel about the classes last year and are any of them still around to continue?

      Good luck

      Stephen Greene

      Dovetail English's picture
      Dovetail English
      Submitted on 22 December, 2011 - 03:49

      Dear Iain

      Thank you for sharing your experiences and hard work with us all out here inESL land. I look forward to reading of your experiences in the second year of this amazing venture, because I am considering teaching in similar environments in Western Australia, where I live and teach.

      I am in contact with the Leonora Detention centre which accommodates families who have arrived in Australia as refugees by boat, and am hoping to start providing English language support to residents there soon.

      The Roebourne prison is 240km south of where I live, and the majority of inmates are aboriginal people who have English as a second and often third language. I am also working towards developing useful and appropriate programmes there as well.

      When I finished my CELTA course in Perth, Western Australia, my fellow students were quite shocked when I said I would be coming back home to Port Hedland to teach ESL. Few people see past the mining boom that is rolling on in the Pilbara, to see the 60+ nationalities represented by the residents here, and the huge demand for flexible English language support.

      Perhaps you could come and have a look one day.

      Best wishes for your course. You are doing a wonderful thing.

      Elizabeth Thomas

      Port Hedland

      Western Australia

      iain's picture
      iain
      Submitted on 22 December, 2011 - 09:59

      Thanks to all of you for your comments and your interest. You're right, Isabel - life inside prison doesn't leave much scope for interests or activities, and the whole sense of wastefulness must be incredibly frustrating. As I said, even if it was just to offer these men an hour away from their cells it would probably be worthwhile, although it would end up being wasteful too in its own way. Being a kind of ‘babysitter’ would be a rather bizarre last resort given the circumstances.

      I don't know exactly to what extent the inmates put their names down for the course to simply escape their cells, or whether they really want to learn or improve their English. I remember a very amusing encounter from last year's course. As we were waiting to start our second lesson one of my students approached me and very politely asked, “Why am I learning English?” I wasn't really sure where he was coming from; the question could have meant different things. “Why am I doing this English course’”, he repeated. Fortunately he saved me from fumbling with possible good reasons for learning English as he went on, “Because I enrolled for cookery lessons.” He turned out to be a very interesting and rather mischievous student in our course. I've seen him since as I've been waiting for my new students and he has been waiting for his bakery instructor - yes he's lucky this year. As he points out, with a 30-year sentence he's going to learn a lot.

      So yes, Steven - to answer your question, all this year's students are new. I also saw another of last year's group at the prison gates. He was very pleased to see me and very pleased to tell me that he is now on a day release scheme which allows him to work outside in preparation for his release in a month or two. His father – another ex-student - is still inside. I learnt that three of my former students have since been released, as they were hoping when our course finished. At the time they all asked if they could come to carry on their course at the school where I work once they were re-established in their outside lives, as they felt it would be a shame to have to stop at this stage having done so much. So this brings us back to the initial point – the lessons were welcome breaks from routine but they were more than just ‘routine’ themselves. It’s a question of finding – or engendering - the spirit of complicity, if that is the right word. You take them seriously and you take your ‘task’ seriously – they take the task seriously and they take you seriously. I don’t want to make this all sound ‘serious’ – being able to get a buzz out of things is essential too, but primarily – if things are to last over months – the buzz comes from seeing and feeling results from the time and effort. This won’t always work for everyone – I had two students drop out mid-way from the last course but the others put them down as ‘time-wasters’. Which was good, because it meant that no-one else was interested in wasting time or the opportunities which that time could afford.  

      iain's picture
      iain
      Submitted on 23 December, 2011 - 15:05

      Hi there Elizabeth,

      Good to hear from you. I’m just doing one group once (twice soon I hope) a week – as a full-time job it’s not for the faint-hearted. The Pilbara sounds a very interesting place – a bit like one of those slave-prison-planets from a sci-fi movie from how you describe it. As you indicate, it’s so much a matter of making the course appropriate to circumstances. Teaching people who already have English as a second language is going to have a different focus from a course for newly-arrived refugees, and different again from foreign residents who are already to some degree integrated socially but lack language skills. I’m lucky in that I work with a very manageable size group – a dozen - and class-size is without doubt one of the biggest single factors in the success of a course, especially if you have no aids or equipment at all: if you have any say in matters emphasise the importance of this to the people in charge. I’m also lucky in that I can teach English as a foreign language, full stop: I don’t have the wider social / cultural / welfare responsibilities that your circumstances could entail.

      Bundling everyone and everything together is unfeasible – whoever organises these courses needs to recognise and address the different circumstances and objectives (and I’m not talking about individual learning styles, levels or specific needs here).      

      aveenglish's picture
      aveenglish
      Submitted on 23 December, 2011 - 17:50

      your story about how to teach inmates sounds really interesting to me. I, myself, am a learner and teacher in english at the same time. So, I found several useful tips in your story and I am totally looking forward to reading the rest of it. By the way as others mentioned, you are doing a great thing. I hope you will be successful.