I have never been a big fan of comic books. Imagine my indignation when it was decided to integrate graphic novels into our high school curriculum! It was a criminal offence to everything I call literature! What made me think better of comics genre? Two things.
1. They say, “Curiosity killed the cat”. In my case, it did not kill the cat but it sure did slaughter prejudice, stereotypes and resistance to the novelty of the idea. I carried out a research into this new genre. Indeed, graphic novels are considered literature. For instance, the comic book American Born Chinese was nominated for National Book Awards in 2006.
Arguments in favor of graphic novels:
- They promote literacy among children of all ages.
- They attract kids’ attention.
- They are suitable for readers with short attention span.
- It doesn’t matter what kids read, literacy is literacy.
- They are academically stimulating.
- They lower affective filter and reduce pressure of L2.
- Visual literacy is an integral part of our students’ lives. Graphic novels are a multimode teaching/learning tool that activates multiple intelligences.
2. However, it was not the research that convinced me. My students did. I saw them finish reading the graphic novels assigned for this term yearly in the first semester. Then, who cares what I like and dislike? Students like comic books, they read, they are engaged. This is all that matters.
Useful links:
A sample lesson plan and materials for “beginners” like me can be found in my previous post.
Graphic Novels in the ESL Classroom.
Are Graphic Novels Literature?
Teaching Graphic Novels as Literature.
- ElenaV's blog
- Login or register to post comments



Comments
I like graphic novels too!
:-)CoffeeAddict
This is a great post!I skipped it the first time but then went back and I am glad I did.
21st century learning is really about unlearning. Unlearning all the out-dated ideas we have about teaching.
What a lot of drama in the department room could be avoided if teachers would be as open minded as you were.
Graphic novels are great for male students, and as you said, differentiated for struggling, and for resistant readers too.
Elena,
I believe comics are great appetizers for our students to form reading habits. For little-aged learners, i think it is a great way to teach. Most of the time, you don't have to motivate students because of the reasons you have written above. I think cartoons are better and more challenging for young adults.
Thanks for the links,
Osman
Hi Elena,
Graphic novels really helps when you want students who are reluctant to read books. Graphic novels are technological adaptations of comic books and I also think using them instead of comic books makes more sense. But, I think we can also use comic books as an alternative. I like reading graphic books, too. So, they can well be used with adult learners, as well.
Thanks for this great post and the links.
Bülent
Hi Bulent,
Have you tried teaching GNs? It's true that students like them, but do you consider graphic novels a literary genre? I'm really curious what other teachers think about it.
Thanks!
Elena